Anastasia's Memorial | Miscellaneous documents | The Case Against Case | Frequently Asked Questions | News stories | Trial Transcripts | Correspondence With a Killer

Returning to the Scene of the Crime (100 Years Earlier)

"The tribulations of the past few weeks have left me a truly broken man. Attending the funerals of my two most cherished friends was a heart-rending experience."
                        --Byron Case, from a fictionalized letter of   "27th December" to his friend "White", web-published fall 20001

"It sickens me that there are so many people desperate for recognition as a 'harrowed soul', that would take something as heartbreaking as death and transform it into a sick mockery, polluting names and legacies. . . I am proud to have no part of that."
                        --Byron Case, from a real email message, 2nd of May to Anastasia's family, sent in 19982

The following are a series of fictionalized correspondence Byron Case created about three years after he murdered Anastasia, at a time when he apparently believed he would escape justice for his acts. There is a well-worn adage that "The criminal always returns to the scene of the crime"; in this case, Byron Case did so, not by physically making a pilgrimage to that infamous spot where he took Anastasia's life from her, but instead by creating a virtual (and fictional) history of the crime as a web story, setting it approximately a century into the past, and (of course) changing key details to protect the guilty, placing with them some rather badly photoshopped pictures of his principal victims.

In this factual-homicide-turned-fictional-epistolary-experiment, Case writes in his first "letter" (to a correspondent known only as "White"; this was created during his first full-blown web stylings as "Monochromatic", when he described everything in shades of black, gray, and of course, white) of his release from prison (the crime he had committed unspoken), mirroring somewhat his real-life release following his burglary arrest and arraignment; he writes of how he is is no longer the "reprehensible soul most remember" following his release.

In other letters, he talks about having been invited to live at Justin's home (something he tried to downplay during his trial), misstates both the time frame of Anastasia's and Justin's breakup (setting it as occuring in late September, when in reality their problems had begun almost three months earlier) as well as his and Kelly's own difficulties (setting that as also starting in late September, when it in reality they began having problems a couple of months after the murder, and only became severe several months after that), and continues with his own personal fiction of the night of Amastasia's murder, all toward the end of buiding the final fiction of his own innocence. He represents himself here as an observer and reporter rather than as a participant.

In one of his letters, dated "21st of September", he mentions that he has become "quite adept at excuses", and that "This shall no doubt be my undoing some day", probably having no idea how prophetic those words would be in the real world.

When going to trial, Case's attorney moved to have all his web page writings suppressed as evidence; there were many accounts and musings that he would have not wanted the jury to see besides this one, and one wonders how he would have tried to explain this one away, had the jury been able to see it.

Herein we present the killer's return to the (revised, edited, and virtualized) scene of the crime.

Click on letters to read

Top of page
Return to Anastasia's memorial
View "The Case Against Case"